In today’s hyperconnected world, our digital identities have become as significant as our real-world personas. Digital identity, in its essence, is the persona we create and present on digital platforms. It encompasses our social media profiles, online interactions, and the digital footprints we leave behind. This concept is well illustrated in Kate Fagan’s poignant article, “Split Image,” which explores the life of Madison Holleran, a University of Pennsylvania student-athlete whose Instagram account portrayed a life of perfection, masking her profound inner struggles.
Photo by alanajordan on Pixabay
The Curated Self
Digital identity often involves a high degree of curation. Social media platforms like Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter allow us to present the best versions of ourselves. We share moments of joy, success, and beauty, often filtering out the mundane or distressing aspects of our lives. In “Split Image,” Madison Holleran’s Instagram posts depicted an idyllic college experience, filled with picturesque scenes and smiling faces. However, this carefully curated digital identity concealed her severe depression and the pressure she felt to maintain this facade.
This phenomenon of curating our online selves can lead to a dissonance between our digital identities and our real lives. We might feel compelled to live up to the personas we project online, which can be mentally and emotionally taxing. The disparity between Madison’s real-life struggles and her digital persona ultimately highlights the dangers of this digital curation.
The Impact of Social Comparison
The digital age has amplified the human tendency for social comparison. With social media, we are constantly bombarded with images and stories of others’ successes and happiness. This can lead to a distorted perception of reality, where we believe everyone else is leading a perfect life. “Split Image” illustrates this through Madison’s story; her followers saw only the beautiful moments she shared, unaware of the pain she was enduring.
This comparison can be detrimental to mental health. It fosters feelings of inadequacy, anxiety, and depression as individuals measure their own lives against the seemingly flawless lives of others. Madison’s tragic story serves as a stark reminder of the pressures that come with maintaining a perfect digital identity and the harmful effects of constant comparison.
The Duality of Digital Identity
Digital identity can often represent a duality – the public persona and the private self. For many, like Madison, the public digital identity is one of happiness and success, while the private self may be struggling with various challenges. This duality can create a sense of isolation, as individuals may feel that their real selves are incongruent with their online personas.
Fagan’s article delves deep into this duality, showing how Madison’s public posts were a stark contrast to her private pain. This highlights a critical issue in the age of social media: the pressure to conform to an idealized digital identity can sometimes overshadow the need to address personal well-being and mental health.
Toward Authentic Digital Identities
The story of Madison Holleran underscores the importance of authenticity in our digital identities. While it is natural to want to present our best selves online, there is a growing movement towards sharing more genuine and unfiltered aspects of life. Authenticity in digital identities can help mitigate the negative effects of social comparison and the pressure to maintain perfection.
By sharing our true selves – including our struggles and imperfections – we can foster a more supportive and realistic online community. This can encourage others to do the same, reducing the stigma around discussing mental health and promoting a more balanced view of life.
Conclusion
Digital identity, as illustrated by Madison Holleran’s story in “Split Image,” is a powerful yet complex aspect of modern life. It is a curated persona that can influence how we perceive ourselves and others. While digital identities allow for self-expression and connectivity, they can also lead to unrealistic expectations and mental health challenges. Striving for authenticity and balance in our online presence can help create a healthier and more supportive digital world. As we navigate the digital landscape, it is crucial to remember that behind every perfect image, there may be a more complicated and nuanced reality.
After reflecting upon what digital identity is, I took a look at a classmate and friend of mine on the Internet to see his digital identity, these were my results.
| Name: Noah Pelletier | |
| Professional (job-related):
– School – Football |
Biographical (age, birthday, location, appearance, etc.):
– University of Regina – Regina – Europe traveling – Graduated in 2020 from highschool – Played for Team Canada Football |
| Personal (relationships, family, hobbies, activities, likes/dislikes, etc.):
– Football – Guitar – Travel |
Where are they on the web? (social networks, job profiles, etc).
– Sports related – Social media (Instagram) – Football Mixtapes |
| Based on their digital footprint, what are your overall impressions of this person?
– Very sports involved – Nothing too personal online – Nothing I found was harmless towards themselves or anyone else |
|
| Based on their digital footprint, do you trust this person? Would you hire them? Would you be their friend? Why or why not?
– With being so successful in whatever he does I would hire him – dedicated and hardworking from what it appears – Can listen to a higher authority from football – transitional – We have similar interests which makes me think we could be friends – I found myself and Noah being very similar |
|
| Based on their digital footprint, what are this person’s beliefs? Political views? How do you know?
– Did not find much about this, was mostly sports dominant – Would believe him to be accepting of all |
|
| What advice would you give this person about their digital footprint?
– Post more about your education journey – Let people know a little bit more about yourself from what you post – mostly football online – Keep up the great work of keeping positive stuff on your profiles |
|