Hello again!
The script for my final project is finally done, but like all scripts it still needs some revision. My target time for my final presentation is 20 minutes, but I feel that I may need freestyle rapping skills to get down to that. The outline for my final three areas of concern (with regards to the ethics of AI) are below.
If you have a chance please take 5 minutes to watch my summary of learning. Thank you for all of your insightful discussions throughout the course.
The theme of this week has been the integration of ideas. I have roughly 40 pages of single space quotes, notes, and musings on the ethical implications of AI from roughly 20 peer reviewed papers, blogs, and websites. What needed to happen this week was the consolidation of this information into a useable form. My process is unusually antiquated given the context of my presentation, but I prefer different coloured highlighters, sticky notes, and tape when it comes to identifying themes in data. I print out my research and lay it out on the ground. I enjoy the physical act of moving from page to page highlighting similar points and identifying key arguments. It looks a bit like a suspect board from a 1990s police procedural show (minus the wool string and pushpins connecting ideas – I am allergic to wool), but it works for me.
As the deadline for my project fast approaches I find myself scrambling to get in “one last article” for fear of missing out on a key idea or insight. The ethical implications of Artificial Intelligence [AI] are far reaching. In my opinion it might be largest technological shift our society has undergone since the advent of the Internet, or the industrialization of manufacturing. My intention this week is to start synthesizing the information I’ve collected and identify key themes.
But there is something still missing.
Since teachers in my province have found themselves thrust into the spotlight (due to contract negotiations) I started to wonder how AI will impact the political process. Everyone is well aware of the foreign election interference in both Canada and the United States. Peddling influence is nothing new. Foreign actors will always try to sway things in their favour (I am sure that we and our security partners have had similar influence campaigns for years), but AI’s ability to work with truly massive data sets presents new opportunities to undermine our institutions. To this end I read an article from the Yale Journal of Law & Technology entitled Artificial Intelligence: Risks to privacy and democracy by Manheim and Kaplan. Below are some of the insights it provided. Continue reading
“The greatest enemy of knowledge is not ignorance, it is the illusion of knowledge.”
– Daniel J. Boorstin
Why are people so dumb? Seriously. Why can’t they see it? This morning I saw this video on YouTube about this politician I hate. He sucks. The guy is basically ruining the country (I’m pretty sure that he’s a traitor). I re-posted it and subscribed to the channel. This country’s going to heck in a handbasket. I don’t know how anyone could miss all of these stories, they’re all over my Facebook feed and Snapchat. The thing is everyone else is basically brainwashed by the media! It’s indoctrination from the schools. Seriously, what are they teaching kids today? I can’t be manipulated like that because I know the truth. Trust me, I do my research. I read a lot about this stuff. Like the other day I heard…
As the deadline for my major project inches ever closer I find myself scrambling to cover blind spots. The main question that I have sought to answer in this project how does AI affects regular everyday people. Intellectual arguments aside, new technologies change our lives, for better or for worse. Ethical boundaries are constantly being pushed by technology and I want to get a grasp of where and how AI redefining what it means to live in our world. One of the inherent problems with a broad topic such as this is looking beyond your own experience. As an able-bodied person I tend to forget that the perspectives of those living and working with disabilities needs to be part of this conversation.
To this end I read through an excellent article by Francisco Jose Bariffi entitled Artificial Intelligence, Human Rights and Disability. In it Bariffi identifies several key areas of concern with regards to AI and its impact on those living with disabilities.
Marantz turntable, closeup on headshell by Paul Joseph, CC BY 2.0
As surprising as it seems one of my interests is visual art. In fact I minored in it in my bachelor degree (approximately 3 rotator cuff tears, 2 strained ACLs, and a mountain of debt ago). I remember in my first art history course the lecturer strode onto stage and boldly proclaimed, “Nothing is created in a vacuum, every song, story, painting, and sculpture ever created was influenced by what came before it.” Admittedly at the time I didn’t fully understand what the professor meant by this (it was an 8:30AM class and I was very tired), but the implications of the statement bear a great deal of significance in our understanding the disagreements around the use of AI in creative and academic spaces.
Cheating by Hariadhi, CC BY-SA 3.0
Generative artificial intelligence (AI) is just another way to lie, cheat, steal, and avoid the hard work of writing, creating, or composing original work. At least that was my initial thoughts before spending any serious amount of time reading about, or understanding how it actually worked. Like many teachers my first serious introduction to the use of AI was seeing my colleagues in the English department thrown into utter turmoil by the deluge of ChatGPT generated essays being submitted as original work. This cemented the idea that generative AI was merely a new way of engaging in dishonesty, much like cheating on an exam, or paying someone else to do your homework.
Saj and Mirror 2016 by Rami Tareef, CC BY-SA 4.0
A life time ago when I was in high school a classmate of mine had a lucrative side hustle selling pirated satellite television boxes. What set him apart from the dozens of others who did this was that he actually wrote the code that circumvented the security protections. Years later our paths crossed again and it turns out that he now runs his own cyber security firm that does consultation work across the country. During our conversation he told me that “Google probably knows you better than you know yourself.” He went on to say my buying habits, location data, search histories, and social media presence create a composite picture of who you are in the digital space.
The idea that my activities are constantly shaping my digital identity was foremost in my mind when it came time to write this week’s blog post. What have I been putting out into the world and what does it say about me? What have I done to help my students nurture a positive online presence? How does the concept of digital identity connect to digital citizenship?
